Bell Statistics

Models and relationships

Regression and the diagnostics around it: what a coefficient claims, what R-squared does not, and the two ways a good-looking model misleads you.

5 terms

Regression is the tool underneath most of the measurement on this site — marketing mix models, variance reduction, matched-market analysis — and the terms here are what it means and how it fails. The failures are worth as much attention as the method, because a model that is wrong in these specific ways still produces confident numbers and a respectable fit statistic.

The first is reading a coefficient as an effect. Regression analysis estimates an association holding the other included variables fixed, and that is a causal claim only if the right variables were included and nothing was left out. The second is trusting fit: R-squared says how much variance the model explains in the data it was fitted on, which is a different thing from whether it will be right about anything new.

Two specific pathologies get their own entries because both are common and neither is visible in the summary output. Multicollinearity — correlated inputs — leaves the model's predictions fine and its individual coefficients unstable, which is fatal precisely when you wanted to read one of them as a channel's contribution. Overfitting is a model that has learned the noise, and it looks best exactly when it is worst.

Terms in this group

  • Correlation

    How tightly two variables move together — bounded, unitless, and silent about cause.

  • Multicollinearity

    When predictors move together the model cannot separate them — good predictions, meaningless coefficients.

  • Overfitting

    A model that memorised the noise — excellent on the data it saw, useless on the data it will meet.

  • R-squared

    Share of variance explained — the most quoted and most over-interpreted number in any model output.

  • Regression analysis

    Fit a line through the data — and the phrase 'holding everything else fixed' is where the trouble starts.